Mystery Oreos remind us of cinnamon. They have a strong cinnamon smell, and the flavor is just as powerful when you try them. Still, Oreo would never choose a mystery flavor as simple as plain cinnamon (or would they?), so the guesses from curious taste-testers.
But then again, there’s a hint of graham cracker flavor to the cream along with the cinnamon. I think it’s possible that the flavor is just cinnamon graham cracker (they smell exactly like one), but the added creaminess could also point toward Dunkaroos.
Choose From Monthly, Yearly and Gift Subscription Options Delivered At Your Doorstep. Sign-up For Newsletter and Get Exclusive Offers & Limited Edition Drops Sent To Your Inbox. Referral Bonus Gift. New Member Gift. Free Shipping.